Love in Four Acts:
What is Romantic Love?
by Nick
Yee
In a strange way, romantic love is the
least understood part of the human psyche because we are content in believing
that “it just happens”, that it is something so sacred that
it clearly resists rational understanding, or that it is an entirely different
experience for everyone such that it is impossible to articulate. Indeed,
social psychology textbooks talk a great deal about the factors that impact
relationship formation (proximity, familiarity, shared attitudes etc),
but they typically do not have a lot to say about romantic love as something
separate from platonic friendships. But perhaps underneath the mystical,
maybe even mythical, glow of love’s façade, there is something
that we can articulate and talk about meaningfully. And perhaps understanding
romantic love empowers us rather than corrupting love through deliberate
exploration. This is a story about romantic love from four different intertwined
perspectives: fairy tales, Jungian psychology, collected interviews, and
biology. This is a story about what four different perspectives can tell
us about romantic love.
It makes the most sense to begin with a clarification of
terminology – what do we mean by “romantic love”? Almost
3 decades ago, in 1978, Elaine Hatfield wrote a seminal book on the topic
of love - teasing apart passionate and companionate love. She defined
passionate love as "a state of intense longing for union with another"
and companionate love as "the affection we feel for those with whom
our lives are deeply entwined". Around the same time, Dorothy
Tennov was trying to answer the same question in her book "Love and
Limerence" and, similar to Hatfield, quickly differentiated between
the “love” that is sincere concern and caring as opposed to
the “love” that is fiery, euphoric and ephemeral. But Tennov
realized that there is something more irrational and complex about this
latter kind of love than what Hatfield described. Tennov coined the term
“limerence” for the latter so as to be able to discuss it
as a concept separate from “love”. She noted that “love”
is an emotion that is acted on, while “limerence” is more
of a transformed state that people go into (the difference in the proverbial
“I love you, but I’m not in love with you”). After interviews
with hundreds of individuals who were "in love", Tennov put
together a list of the symptoms of limerence:
1) Intrusive thoughts about the object of passionate desire (the “limerent object” or LO)
2) Acute longing for reciprocation
3) Mood becomes dependent on the LO’s actions
4) Inability to react limerently towards more than one person at the same time (except when limerence is at low ebb)
5) Unsettling shyness and fear of rejection when in the presence of the LO
6) Intensification through adversity (up to a certain point)
7) Acute sensitivity to any act or condition that could be interpreted as favorable
8) An aching of the “heart” (a palpable heavy sensation in the front of the chest)
9) Buoyancy (a feeling of “walking on air”)
10) An intensity of feeling that leaves other concerns in the background
11) A remarkable ability to emphasize the positive traits of the LO, while rendering the LO’s negative traits as “endearing” to the point where it is perceived to be another positive trait. --- (pg. 23)
The central paradox of limerence is that someone who is
actively limerent feels like they are experiencing the most unique, rapturous
experience in the world even though limerence seems to have fairly universal
characteristics (at least in Western cultures, although it could be argued
that traditional Asian cultures do understand limerence but don't use
it as a basis for marriage). In fact, as Tennov noted, there is a very
well-rehearsed cultural script for falling in and out of limerence: the
initial buoyancy, the ensuing anxiety and self-consciousness, intense
distraction and euphoria, usually followed by a devastating disillusionment.
Everyone knows this script.
And one reason why we know this script so well is because
we’ve been hearing about it since we were children. We have all
gone to bed as a child with the freshly-told fairy tale story still bubbling
in our mind. Marcia Lieberman has criticized fairy tales as conditioning
girls into becoming submissive women who believe that beauty and docility
are the only traits that are rewarded in life, but in her essay “Some
Day My Prince Will Come”, she also points out something very interesting
about romantic love itself. Most fairy tales end with the “happily
ever after” clause, but these same fairy tales almost always have
the protagonist come from a broken family. Either one of the parents is
dead, missing, or there is an evil step-parent. These fairy tales imply
that romantic love leads to happy marriages and yet all the families that
they portray are broken. The paradox of love in fairy tales is that everyone
ends up happily ever after, but no one seems to be happy. The “happily
ever after” of love is always emphasized, but never shown.
What does it mean to grow up with stories with such a strange
juxtaposition of what romantic love is? But in fact, these symbols and
themes still surround us as adults. The prince and princess merely change
forms and show up on TV sitcoms, movies and fill the roles in novels,
plays and even songs. The same story is being re-enacted over and over
again for all ages.
In his book “We: Understanding the Psychology of Romantic
Love”, Robert Johnson shows how we grow up to believe in the irrational
assumptions of the fairy tale script of romantic love. As a Jungian analyst,
Robert Johnson is interested in exploring the cultural archetype of romantic
love to uncover its psychological essence and meaning. Like Tennov, he
differentiates romantic love from sincere love – “Romantic
love is not love but a complex of attitudes about love –
involuntary feelings, ideals, and reactions” (pg. 45, original emphasis).
Johnson points out a central ideal of love that Tennov doesn’t emphasize
and it is this:
When we are “in love” we feel completed, as though a missing part of ourselves had been returned to us; we feel uplifted, as though we were suddenly raised above the level of the ordinary world. Life has an intensity, a glory, an ecstasy and transcendence (pg. 52)
For Johnson, romantic love is a kind of primal religious
experience – both revelation and rapture - that is a fundamental
part of our collective unconsciousness. The tragedy of our cultural understanding
of romantic love is that it makes us place unreasonable demands on our
romantic partners because we believe that they have “the responsibility
for making our lives whole … making our lives meaningful, intense,
and ecstatic” (pg. 61).
The cause of the problem is that when we are in love, we
become “entranced, mesmerized … with a mystical vision –
but of something separate and distinct from [our] human selves”
(pg. 51). We see our romantic partners as idealized, god-like versions
of who they are. And we are euphoric with this vision instead of the other
person. For Johnson, the paradox of romantic love is that “it never
produces human relationships as long as it stays romantic” (pg.
133) because we are in love with our own fantastical creations instead
of the other person for who they really are.
More tragically, “we assume that the single ingredient
that we need for ‘relationship’ … is romance”
(pg. 103) and that a relationship without this heady, fiery kind of love
has very little worth to the point where “if a direct, uncomplicated,
simple relationship offers us happiness, we won’t accept it”
(pg. 134). The tragedy derives from the simple fact that romantic love
always fades, and most people do not know how to derive a sincere, human
relationship from one that is fantastical and rapturous. And if they learned
anything from fairy tales, they learned that a relationship without romantic
love is worthless. All their lives, they have had a vision of what love
would be, and they now believe that their “true love” must
then still be out there waiting for them. Many people are stuck forever
in this wash-and-rinse cycle of romantic love because they believe that
fiery romantic love can be everlasting.
The romantic couples who have been together for half their
lives have something quite different from romantic love. Johnson calls
it “stirring-the-oatmeal” love – “it represents
a willingness to share ordinary human life, to find meaning in the simple,
unromantic tasks … to find the relatedness, the value, the beauty,
in the simple and ordinary things, not to eternally demand a cosmic drama
… or an extraordinary intensity in everything” (pg. 195).
In a strange way, this is true love because it can be everlasting, but
this is not the love script that we are bombarded with from every literary
or entertainment form in our lives.
Yet if romantic love or limerence is so destructive and
irrational, why does it happen at all? Tennov briefly ponders the possible
biological underpinnings of limerence in her book. As an evolutionary
adaptation, limerence might be a reaction to a set of physical attractiveness
or genetic fitness cues. Prima facie, it makes a lot of sense that we
become intensely attracted to highly desirable sexual partners, but that
is lust – an intense erotic reaction, which is different from limerence
– the set of responses and attitudes that can be independent from
sexual desire. When we are in limerence with someone, we want to be with
them and we want them to like us. When we are in lust with someone, we
just want to have sex with them. There is an important difference between
the two. It makes sense for us to lust a highly desirable sexual partner,
but why would we become limerent over them?
The answer may lie with the size of our brains. Our pelvises
have decreased in size over the past few million years while the size
of our brains have increased. The problem is that babies cannot fully
develop in the mother’s womb otherwise they would be too large to
be given birth to. The compromise is that human infants are born “pre-mature”
so they can finish developing outside the womb. But this leaves both the
mother and infant highly vulnerable in the small tribal hunter-gatherer
environment. This is particularly because human infants cannot cling onto
their mothers the way all primate infants can (a consequence of hairlessness
and shorter arms). In fact, the only way a human infant can survive in
the ancestral environment is if both parents are present. Limerence is
perhaps an evolutionary adaptation that creates an irrational emotional
attachment to another individual for the likely duration of conception,
birth and child care. This duration is around 2-3 years, which is also
how long marriages usually last – long enough to bear one child
and for that child to be old enough to walk.
Of course, Tennov is probably right that limerence is triggered
by some set of traits that imply genetic fitness (such as physical attractiveness)
which differ from person to person. For example, it has been shown that
we are attracted to or repelled by the natural body odor of other individuals
to differing degrees. Research has shown that we are typically not attracted
to the body odors of close family members (another incest safeguard) or
people whose genetic makeup is very different from ours. We typically
find individuals who are in the optimal middle area most erotic-smelling.
The underlying theory is that the pheromones in our body odor are a signature
of our immune system blueprint, and one reason why sex exists to begin
with is to increase genetic variation against the constantly evolving
viruses and bacteria. It’s essentially an arms race between us and
viruses that forces us to increase the genetic variation of our offspring
or perish. In short, limerence as an evolutionary adaptation is plausible.
Many of us have at one point or another been imprisoned
by the painful, irrational clutches of limerence gone bad. But in a culture
where romantic “love” is often presented in entirely paradoxical
ways, it is inevitable that many people are unable to untangle limerence
from love. Romantic love and all its implications are deeply rooted in
our culture, and perhaps these irrational reactions have evolutionary
underpinnings, but that does not mean we have to be imprisoned by them.
For as long as we project god-like idealizations onto our romantic partners
and demand that they make us happy as the fairy tales describe, we will
never truly love them as human beings. Limerence may be a wonderful way
to begin a relationship, but that relationship will never get anywhere
unless both individuals are willing and able to see each other for who
they are. In the end, the basis of a stable relationship is founded on
a love that emerges not in spite of but because of the other person’s
flaws and weaknesses, because ultimately it is our imperfections that
make us human. We can seek out limerence with angels, but we can only
find true love among mortals.
| ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
Notes:
1) One of the things that started Tennov on her study of
limerence was her discovery of natural non-limerents - people who do not
experience limerence and not because they are actively denying their own
emotions. Tennov documents several individuals she meets who have never
been limerent and are confused by the media portrayal of this set of emotions
and attitudes. A biological underpinning actually does allow for a spectrum
of "limerent reactions" with individuals on both ends of that
spectrum.
2) Robert Sternberg has a triarchic theory of love, composed
of 3 factors: Intimacy, Passion and Commitment, and in his paradigm, you
need all 3 to have "consummate" love. While this may seem to
contradict what Tennov and Johnson say, this may be caused by Sternberg's
more mild conceptualization of Passion which does not include the more
irrational, emotionally-charged, drama-ridden elements that Tennov and
Johnson describe. Sternberg's Passion is better described as warm romance.
References:
Hatfield, E., & Walster, G. W.
(1978). A new look at love. Addison-Wesley.
Johnson, Robert A. We: Understanding
the Psychology of Romantic Love. Harper San Francisco. 1983.
Lieberman, Marcia K. "'Some Day My Prince Will Come': Female Acculturation through the Fairy Tale." In Don't Bet on the Prince: Contemporary Feminist Fairy Tales in North America and England. Ed. Jack Zipes. New York: Methuen, 1986, pp. 185-200.
Tennov, Dorothy. Love and Limerence. Scarborough House. 1979.
Thornhill, Randy, Gangestad, Steven W. The scent of symmetry: A human sex pheromone that signals fitness? Evolution & Human Behavior Vol 20(3) (May 1999): 175-201
Lieberman, Marcia K. "'Some Day My Prince Will Come': Female Acculturation through the Fairy Tale." In Don't Bet on the Prince: Contemporary Feminist Fairy Tales in North America and England. Ed. Jack Zipes. New York: Methuen, 1986, pp. 185-200.
Tennov, Dorothy. Love and Limerence. Scarborough House. 1979.
Thornhill, Randy, Gangestad, Steven W. The scent of symmetry: A human sex pheromone that signals fitness? Evolution & Human Behavior Vol 20(3) (May 1999): 175-201